Now accepting new patients. Schedule a visit.

ACL Repair vs. ACL Reconstruction: What’s the Difference and Which Is Right for You?

acl repair vs reconstruction

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries are among the most common and devastating injuries in sports, often requiring surgical intervention to restore knee stability and function. When an ACL is torn, patients typically face two primary surgical options: ACL repair and ACL reconstruction. While both procedures aim to restore knee function and allow patients to return to their active lifestyles, they are fundamentally different in terms of technique, recovery, and long-term outcomes. Understanding the differences between ACL repair and ACL reconstruction can help patients make informed decisions about their treatment options.

1. What Is ACL Repair?

Technique: ACL repair involves reattaching the torn ends of the original ligament to the bone. This procedure is only possible if the tear occurs in a location where the ligament can be reattached, such as at the ligament’s insertion point on the bone. During ACL repair, the surgeon uses sutures, anchors, or other fixation devices to reattach the torn ligament and secure it in place.

Ideal Candidates:

Advantages:

Disadvantages:

2. What Is ACL Reconstruction?

Technique: ACL reconstruction involves replacing the torn ligament with a graft, which can be harvested from the patient’s own body (autograft) or from a donor (allograft). Common graft options include the patellar tendon, hamstring tendon, or quadriceps tendon. During the procedure, the surgeon creates tunnels in the bone to pass the graft through and secure it in place, effectively creating a new ligament that can perform the functions of the original ACL.

Ideal Candidates:

Advantages:

Disadvantages:

3. Choosing Between ACL Repair and ACL Reconstruction

The decision between ACL repair and ACL reconstruction depends on several factors, including the nature of the injury, the patient’s activity level, and the goals for recovery.

4. The Future of ACL Surgery: Emerging Techniques

The field of ACL surgery is continuously evolving, with new techniques and technologies being developed to improve outcomes for patients. For example, some surgeons are exploring the use of biological augmentation, such as platelet-rich plasma (PRP) or stem cells, to enhance the healing process in both ACL repair and reconstruction. Additionally, improvements in surgical techniques and rehabilitation protocols continue to reduce recovery times and improve long-term knee function.

Conclusion

Both ACL repair and ACL reconstruction offer pathways to recovery after an ACL injury, but they are distinctly different procedures with unique advantages and challenges. ACL repair may be an option for select patients with specific types of tears and offers a potentially quicker recovery. However, ACL reconstruction remains the gold standard for most ACL injuries, particularly for active individuals and those with complete tears.

Choosing the right procedure involves careful consideration of the injury’s specifics, the patient’s lifestyle, and the surgeon’s expertise. By understanding the differences between ACL repair and ACL reconstruction, patients can make informed decisions that align with their long-term health and activity goals.

At Princeton Sports and Family Medicine, P.C., our doctors specialize in sports medicine services, including exercise counseling and physician services to assess your risk for injury and assist in your performance goals.

Call or click to book a session with our professionals at Princeton Sports and Family Medicine, P.C. In addition to problem-focused visits, we offer sports performance evaluations to stop problems before they start. Plan your visit today!

Author
Peter Wenger, MD Peter C. Wenger, MD, is an orthopedic and non-operative sports injury specialist at Princeton Sports and Family Medicine, P.C., in Lawrenceville, New Jersey. He is board certified in both family medicine and sports medicine. Dr. Wenger brings a unique approach to sports medicine care with his comprehensive understanding of family medicine, sports medicine, and surgery. As a multisport athlete himself, he understands a patient’s desire to safely return to their sport.

You Might Also Enjoy...

Title: Cognitive and Emotional Signs of a Concussion

Cognitive and Emotional Signs of a Concussion

Signs of a concussion generally fall into four categories: physical, sleep-related, cognitive, and emotional. The cognitive and emotional effects of concussions are sometimes challenging to recognize and treat. 
5 Ways to Ease Your Back Pain for Good

5 Ways to Ease Your Back Pain for Good

Virtually everyone experiences back pain at some point. For many, it’s an occasional issue brought on by exertion or a minor injury. Fortunately, many people ease back pain for good with lifestyle changes and modifications.
 A Closer Look at Pediatric Sports Medicine

 A Closer Look at Pediatric Sports Medicine

It’s easy to think of children as mini versions of adults. However, bones and soft tissue respond differently in pediatric athletes than they will after physical maturity. Keep reading to learn more.
Benefits of Physical Therapy

Benefits of Physical Therapy

Physical therapy uses your body’s natural healing abilities to reduce pain and increase mobility. It’s a powerful treatment when you’re dealing with an injury, chronic pain, or rehab after surgery.